NERC PRC-025 Compliance

Generator Relay Loadability Compliance Support

eGridSync helps Generator Owners ensure protective relays do not improperly trip generators during normal or emergency loading conditions, preventing cascading outages during system stress.

Request PRC-025 Scope Checklist Talk to a Protection Engineer

What is NERC PRC-025?

PRC-025 addresses generator protection relay loadability to prevent unnecessary generator trips that could worsen grid emergencies.

Generator Protection Focus

Ensures generator protective relays allow full capability operation without improper trips during normal or emergency loading conditions

Prevents Cascading Outages

Stops unnecessary generator loss when the grid needs generation the most, avoiding cascading failures during system stress

Capability Coordination

Relay settings must respect generator capability curves including continuous and emergency ratings at all power factors

Critical Reliability Impact

Improper relay settings can cause widespread generation loss during emergencies, triggering frequency decline or voltage collapse

Who Must Comply with PRC-025?

PRC-025 applies to Generator Owners of BES generators with specific protective relay functions that may limit generator output.

Generator Owners (GO)

Entities owning BES generators above applicability thresholds with covered protective relay types

BES Generators

Generators connected at transmission levels or classified as Bulk Electric System resources

Covered Relay Types

Loss-of-field, distance, voltage-controlled overcurrent, impedance, and frequency relays

Applicability Note: PRC-025 focuses on relays that could trip generators during normal or emergency loading. Not all generator protection is covered—only relays sensitive to generator output levels, voltage, or impedance characteristics.

Understanding Generator Relay Loadability

Loadability ensures protective relays allow generators to operate throughout their full capability without spurious trips.

Generator Capability Curves

Capability curves define the MW-MVAR operating envelope of a generator considering armature heating, field heating, end-turn heating, and stability limits. Relay settings must not encroach on this operating space under any credible system voltage or load condition.

Continuous vs Emergency Loading

Continuous ratings allow indefinite operation. Emergency ratings permit temporary overload for specified durations (15-minute, 2-hour). Relays must accommodate both without tripping, as emergency loading may be required during system contingencies.

Relay Characteristics vs Generator Limits

Distance relays, loss-of-field relays, and voltage-controlled overcurrent relays all respond to generator output characteristics. Their operating zones must be coordinated with capability curves, accounting for voltage variations (±5% to ±10%) and all credible operating conditions.

Coordination Requirements

Relay settings must be technically justified with engineering analysis showing they do not operate within the generator's capability. This requires plotting relay characteristics against capability curves on impedance or power diagrams, considering all voltage and loading scenarios.

What eGridSync Delivers for PRC-025 Compliance

PRC-025 applicability determination and gap assessment

Generator capability curve review and validation

Relay type and function identification for all BES generators

Settings evaluation against capability curves

Coordination analysis with capability and voltage variations

Documentation and evidence package preparation

Remediation recommendations for non-compliant settings

Audit preparation and mitigation support

Inputs Required for PRC-025 Implementation

To evaluate and ensure PRC-025 compliance, eGridSync requires access to the following data:

Item	Examples	Why Required
Generator Ratings & Capability Curves	MW, MVAR, P-Q curves, continuous/emergency ratings, power factor limits	Define loadability limits that relays must not violate
One-Line Diagrams	Generator connections, protection zones, relay locations, CT/PT ratios	Identify all applicable protective relays
Relay Settings Files	Distance (21), loss-of-field (40), overcurrent (51V) settings and curves	Evaluate whether settings permit full capability operation
Relay Type & Firmware	Manufacturer, model, version, relay characteristic curves	Understand relay behavior and operating characteristics
Protection Philosophy Documents	Design basis, coordination approach, settings rationale, protection zones	Provide context for existing protection schemes
Prior Loadability Studies	Existing PRC-025 studies, relay coordination reports, protection reviews	Establish baseline and identify previous assessments
Historical Relay Operations	Trip logs, event reports, nuisance trips, operational issues	Identify field evidence of loadability problems
Audit History	Previous NERC findings, mitigation plans, corrective actions	Address known compliance gaps and prevent recurrence

Common PRC-025 Compliance Failure Points

Understanding common pitfalls helps Generator Owners avoid violations and maintain reliable protection:

Relays Set Below Generator Capability

Protective relay operating zones that encroach on generator capability curves during normal or emergency loading. This occurs when relays are set conservatively without analyzing capability limits, causing unnecessary trips during high output or low voltage conditions.

Lack of Coordination Documentation

Missing engineering analysis demonstrating relay settings coordinate with capability curves. Auditors require impedance diagrams, power diagrams, or time-current curves showing relay characteristics do not operate within capability limits across all voltage scenarios.

Missing Justification for Settings

Relay settings without documented technical justification explaining why they do not interfere with generator operation. Every applicable relay requires engineering rationale showing compliance with PRC-025 loadability requirements.

Incomplete Relay Inventory

Failing to identify all applicable protective relays on BES generators. Generator protection schemes often include multiple relay types—distance, loss-of-field, voltage-controlled overcurrent, under/over frequency. All must be evaluated for PRC-025 compliance.

Capability Changes Not Reflected

Generator capability modifications (rerates, excitation upgrades, cooling changes) without corresponding relay setting reviews. When capability changes, relay loadability analysis must be repeated to ensure continued compliance.

Vendor Defaults Used Without Analysis

Applying manufacturer default relay settings without validating they meet PRC-025 requirements for the specific generator. Default settings are generic and rarely account for individual generator capability characteristics.

Coordination Studies Outdated

Using relay coordination studies performed years ago without verification they remain valid. System voltage changes, generator modifications, or new relay installations require updated loadability assessments to maintain compliance.

PRC-025 Audit & Evidence Expectations

Auditors verify PRC-025 compliance through relay setting reviews and capability coordination documentation:

Settings vs Capability Must Be Documented

Every applicable relay must have documented analysis showing its operating characteristics do not encroach on generator capability. This requires capability curves plotted with relay characteristics on impedance or power diagrams, demonstrating adequate margin under all operating conditions.

Clear Engineering Justification Required

Technical rationale must explain relay setting choices and demonstrate PRC-025 compliance. Justifications must reference capability curves, voltage assumptions, power factor ranges, and coordination methodology. Generic statements are insufficient.

Traceability: Generator → Relay → Setting → Documentation

Auditors trace from physical generators to installed relays to active settings to supporting documentation. Breaks in this chain create findings. Documentation must clearly identify which relays protect which generators and how settings were validated.

Coordination Curves Mandatory

Visual representation of relay characteristics overlaid on capability curves is standard evidence. Impedance diagrams (R-X plots) for distance and loss-of-field relays, or time-current curves for overcurrent relays, must show relay zones clear of generator operating regions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is PRC-025?

PRC-025 is a NERC Reliability Standard requiring Generator Owners to ensure protective relays allow generators to operate up to their full capability limits without improper tripping. It prevents cascading outages caused by generator loss during system stress. Relays must be set to coordinate with generator capability curves and operating limits.

Who must comply with PRC-025?

PRC-025 applies to Generator Owners (GO) of BES generators above specified thresholds. It covers generators connected at transmission voltage levels and larger distribution-connected units classified as BES resources. Applicability depends on generator size, voltage, and BES classification.

What is relay loadability?

Relay loadability refers to a relay's ability to allow maximum generator loading without tripping. Protective relays must be set to permit operation throughout the generator's capability curve, including continuous and emergency ratings. Settings must account for voltage variations, power factor ranges, and system conditions.

Why is generator tripping a reliability risk?

Unexpected generator trips during high-load or emergency conditions remove generation capacity when the grid needs it most. This can trigger cascading outages, frequency decline, voltage collapse, or load shedding. PRC-025 prevents relay-induced trips from worsening system emergencies.

What relays are covered?

PRC-025 covers generator protective relays including loss-of-field (40), distance (21), voltage-controlled or voltage-restrained overcurrent (51V), and other relays that could trip during loadability conditions. The standard focuses on relays that may respond to normal or emergency generator output levels.

How do capability curves affect settings?

Capability curves define the MW-MVAR operating envelope a generator can sustain. Relay settings must not operate within this envelope under any credible voltage or loading scenario. Engineers plot relay characteristics against capability curves to verify adequate coordination margins exist.

What evidence is required?

Evidence includes capability curves, relay settings, coordination diagrams (impedance or power plots), engineering justification documents, and voltage scenario analysis. Documentation must demonstrate each relay permits full generator capability operation without spurious trips.

How often must PRC-025 be reviewed?

PRC-025 compliance must be reviewed whenever generator capability changes, relay settings are modified, or new relays are installed. Many Generator Owners perform periodic reviews annually or when capability rerates occur to ensure ongoing compliance.

What are common audit findings?

Common findings include relay settings encroaching on capability curves, missing coordination documentation, lack of engineering justification, incomplete relay inventories, outdated studies not reflecting current capability, and failure to account for voltage variations in loadability analysis.

How do we correct non-compliant settings?

Non-compliant settings require engineering analysis to determine appropriate adjustments. Options include revising relay settings to clear capability curves, changing relay types, upgrading to modern relays with better characteristics, or justifying generator capability reductions. All changes must be documented and validated.

Do vendor default settings meet PRC-025?

Vendor default settings are generic and rarely meet PRC-025 requirements without customization. Each generator has unique capability characteristics requiring tailored relay settings. Default settings must be evaluated against specific capability curves and adjusted as needed.

How does PRC-025 relate to PRC-019?

PRC-019 addresses transmission relay loadability, while PRC-025 addresses generator relay loadability. Both prevent improper relay trips during high loading. Generator Owners must ensure generator protection coordinates with both generator capability (PRC-025) and transmission system needs (PRC-019).

What happens if generator capability changes?

Capability changes (rerates, excitation upgrades, cooling modifications) require PRC-025 reassessment. Relay settings must be reviewed against new capability limits and updated if necessary. Documentation must reflect the revised capability and demonstrate continued relay coordination.

How long does PRC-025 compliance take?

Achieving initial PRC-025 compliance typically takes 2-4 months per generator depending on relay complexity, data availability, and documentation quality. This includes capability review, relay settings analysis, coordination studies, evidence preparation, and remediation if needed.

How does eGridSync support audits?

eGridSync provides organized evidence packages including capability curves, relay settings documentation, coordination diagrams, engineering justifications, and traceability matrices. We prepare audit-ready documentation and can support Generator Owners during NERC data requests and on-site reviews.

Official References

For complete standard requirements and technical guidelines, refer to official NERC resources:

NERC PRC-025-2 Official PDF

Current version of the PRC-025 Reliability Standard

NERC Reliability Standards Library

Complete library of all NERC Reliability Standards

Important: This page summarizes PRC-025 compliance concepts in original language for educational purposes. Always refer to the official NERC standard for authoritative requirements. eGridSync does not copy or reproduce NERC standard text.

Ready to Ensure PRC-025 Compliance?

For generator relay loadability studies, coordination analysis, and PRC-025 compliance support, contact eGridSync today.

Start Your PRC-025 Assessment Learn More About eGridSync